BMW X5 Best and Worst Years (Top Picks!)

For the 2000 luxury model year, the BMW X5 was first offered as a high-end midsize SUV.

It features high-end interior details, powerful powertrain options, and excellent performance.

Here, we look at its finest and worst years.

VIDEO: Buying A Used BMW X5 E70

BMW X5 Best and Worst Years

The 2013 BMW X5 is one of the worst years to stay away from, according to CoPilotSearch.com, as it received a poor 1 out of 5 reliability rating from Consumer Reports. The worst years for the BMW X5 according to CarProper.com are 2001, 2008, 2011, 2012, and 2013, while the best years are 2000, 2016, 2017, 2018, and 2020. According to VehicleHistory.com, there have been four generations of the BMW X5, with the current G05 model coming from 2019. There isn’t much information available on the BMW cars that is X4’s best and worst years. EnginePatrol.com notes that the X4 has seen both excellent and bad years, with the worst model year being the 2018 X4 as a result of documented issues with its inside accessories and sharp edges on doors. When choosing a vehicle, it’s crucial to put reliability first and to keep up with any official recalls or safety issues.

What Are The BMW X5’s Best Years?

2023 and 2022 BMW X5

The most upscale iterations of the moniker are the BMW X5 luxury vehicle from 2023 and 2022, and they do not dissapoint.

There aren’t any significant distinctions between these models; they are virtually the same.

The X5 has a V8 or six-cylinder engine option, and both deliver potent performance and agile handling.

The Climate Comfort package, which includes heated seats, armrests, and a four-zone automated climate control system, was first introduced in 2022.

Wireless charging and fog lights were removed, while new paint colors were added.

2023 BMW X5:

• Edmunds: 4.8 out of 5
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• JD Power: 80 out of 100

2022 BMW X5:

• Edmunds: 4.3 out of 5
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• 80 of 100 for JD Power

2021 BMW X5

The plug-in hybrid xDrive45e model was introduced to replace the xDrive50i model for the 2021 BMW X5 Model. 

It has a 3-liter inline-six engine and an electric motor that enable it to travel up to 30 miles on electricity alone.

A 48-volt mild hybrid system was installed in the X 5 Series 40i versions.

The Kelley Blue Books “Best Buy Award” for 2021 went to the X5.

• Edmunds: 4 out of 5
•  
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• JD Power: 79 out of 100

2020 BMW X5

A reliable option from the car line nicknamed “the Godfather of premium crossovers” is the 2020 BMW X5.

A new V8-powered M50i model was added to the lineup for 2020; these vehicles come complete with wireless phone charging and a Wi-Fi hotspot.

The rear-drive sDrive40i, which has an excellent turbocharged six-cylinder, was the entry-level model.

• Edmunds: 4.1 out of 5
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
•  
• JD Power rating: 81/100

2019 BMW X5

The 2019 BMW X5 was the first model of the fourth generation and featured a ton of new driving and technological features.

The X5 lineup for 2019 included two potent engine options and all-wheel drive as standard.

This design was lauded for emphasizing driving characteristics, which were responsible for the car’s early popularity.

• Edmunds: 3.7 out of 5
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• 80 of 100 for JD Power

BMW X5 from 2018 and 2017

The third generation of the BMW X5 was debuted in 2014, and the 2018 and 2017 models were the final variants. Both vehicles were quite dependable and received few complaints on the NHTSA website.

Other than this, there were no significant changes made to the 2018 X5, save that the plug-in hybrid xDrive40e variant now comes standard with paddle shifters.

Minor updates to the 2017 X5 include an inbuilt Wi-Fi hotspot system, wireless smartphone charging, and an improved software package for the touchscreen display.

2018 BMW X5:

• Edmunds: 4.2 out of 5
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• JD Power rating: 81/100

2017 BMW X5:

• Edmunds: 4.3 out of 5
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• 80 of 100 for JD Power

2016 BMW X5

The 2016 X5 is yet another standout option when looking for an SUV that drives like a performance sedan.

The plug-in hybrid xDrive40e variant was unveiled for 2016.

This model had a lithium-ion battery pack and a turbocharged four-cylinder engine.

It provides a 56 mpg fuel efficiency and 13 miles of all-electric range.

• Edmunds: 4.3 out of 5
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• JD Power rating: 81/100

2014 BMW X5

As it entered its third generation, the 2014 BMW X5 was completely newer models.

It was completely revamped and included minor upgrades everywhere without compromising dependability.

The engines were updated, the internal space was significantly increased, and it had a long list of technological innovations for highway safety.

• Edmunds: 4.4 out of 5
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• JD Power: 79 out of 100

2005 BMW X5

A 2005 variant of the X5 is the only slightly older X5 with a track record of dependability.

Both automated climate control and front lumbar supports were standard for 2005.

Standard park distance control was attained with the 4.4i type.

Auto reviewers praised this model for its high safety ratings and well-appointed interior.

• Edmunds: 4.61 out of 5
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• N/A JD Power

2004 BMW X5

Another dependable classic with a variety of drivetrain options is the 2004 X5.

Exterior improvements and a brand-new all-wheel-drive technology known as the xDrive were added to the 3.0i and 4.4i for 2004.

The 3.0i received a new six-speed manual transmission as well as a six-speed automatic transmission as standard equipment, while the 4.4i received a new 4.4-liter engine. 

The powerful X5 4.6is model was dropped.

• Edmunds: 4.7 out of 5
• 4.4 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• N/A JD Power

2003 BMW X5

Few people complained about the 2003 X5, which was hailed for having remarkable driving dynamics.

Additionally revolutionary at the time was the inclusion of a DVD-based navigation system.

Additionally, a number of extra packages were added, rear head protection airbags were made standard, and brakeforce display (additional rear lights during emergency braking) was added. 

• Edmunds: 4.7 out of 5
• 4.4 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• N/A JD Power

2002 BMW X5

The 2002 BMW X5 has received favorable evaluations from car reviewers as well as high ratings from consumers.

A lightning-fast X5 4.6iS variant with a 4.6-liter V8 engine was released for 2002.

The 4.4-liter V8 engine was modified to produce a total of 290 horsepower, an increase from the 282 horsepower of the previous model year.

Other new features included a self-leveling suspension, improved hill descent control, and trailer stability control.

• Edmunds: 4.61 out of 5
• 4.4 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• N/A JD Power

2000 BMW X5

The 2000 X5 is the first model year ever created under the designation of SAV (Sports Activity Vehicle). 

It was well-liked for its ability to handle like a typical BMW sedan while providing a superior ride with opulent accoutrements.

A potent 4.4-liter eight-cylinder engine and four-wheel independent suspension are included as standard equipment on this model.

• Edmunds: 4.4 out of 5
• 4.5 out of 5.0 on Kelley Blue Book
• N/A JD Power

Consumer Scores For Best BMW X5 Years

Model Year	EdmundsConsumer Rating	Kelley Blue BookConsumer Rating	JD PowerConsumer Rating
2023 BMW X5	4.8 / 5.0	4.5 / 5.0	80 / 100
2022 BMW X5	4.3 / 5.0	4.5 / 5.0	80 / 100
2021 BMW X5	4.0 / 5.0	4.5 / 5.0	79 / 100
2020 BMW X5	4.1 / 5.0	4.5 / 5.0	81 / 100
2019 BMW X5	3.7 / 5.0	4.5 / 5.0	80 / 100
2018 BMW X5	4.2 / 5.0	4.5 / 5.0	81 / 100
2017 BMW X5	4.3 / 5.0	4.5 / 5.0	80 / 100
2016 BMW X5	4.3 / 5.0	4.5 / 5.0	81 / 100
2014 BMW X5	4.4 / 5.0	4.5 / 5.0	79 / 100
2005 BMW X5	4.6 / 5.0	4.5 / 5.0	NA
2004 BMW X5	4.7 / 5.0	4.4 / 5.0	NA
2003 BMW X5	4.7 / 5.0	4.4 / 5.0	NA
2002 BMW X5	4.6 / 5.0	4.4 / 5.0	NA
2000 BMW X5	4.4 / 5.0	4.4 / 5.0	NA

What Are The BMW X5’s Worst Years?

Below is a list of the model years for the X5 that had a significant amount of complaints.

 2013 BMW X5

The 2013 BMW X5’s greatest issues were with the engine and powerplant.

Owners experienced troubles with the cooling system, slow throttle response, and smoke coming from the engine.

The infamous Takata airbag recall also applied to this particular model.

The airbags were known to detonate and spew metal shards into the cabin, perhaps killing passengers.

At CarComplaints.com, the 2013 X5 received a total of 15 complaints, while CarProblemZoo.com recorded 183 issues.

Common issues:

• Engine heats up
• transmission problem

2012 BMW X5

While operating a 2012 BMW X5, the transmission changes to neutral.

The 2012 X5’s engine and powertrain problems received the greatest reports of complaints.

Engine overheating and malfunctioning were the main complaints.

Total complaints and difficulties for the 2012 X5 were 17 at CarComplaints.com and 363 at CarProblemZoo.com.

Common issues:

• A lot of vibration
• Recall of Takata airbags
• heating-related engine failure
• Oil and metal

2011 BMW X5

According to data, of all X5 model years ever made, the 2011 X5 has had the most complaints and problems. 

Some of the more well-known difficulties experienced by owners of this model year were random noises, unpredictable shifting, intermittent warning indicators going off, engine troubles, and complete gearbox failure. 

The 2011 X5 was the subject of 403 common problems at CarProblemZoo.com and a total of 22 complaints at CarComplaints.com.

Common issues:

• driving while stalled
• Warns of engine overheating
• lost power to the dashboard cluster

2010 BMW X5

For the 2010 X5, the powertrain was generally highly problematic.

Many owners of this model year reported problems with the transmission shifting and jerking, poor circulation of cooling fluids, sporadic engine stalling, and other problems. 

181 issues and 6 complaints in total were found for the 2010 X5 at CarProblemZoo.com and CarComplaints.com, respectively.

Common issues:

• the gearbox failed
• Vehicle jerks out of gear
• While driving, the engine sputters and stops.
• No battery can maintain a charge.

2009 BMW X5

The airbags in the 2009 BMW X5 were particularly problematic, with issues ranging from failure to deploy to instrument cluster airbag warning signs beeping and lighting up. 

Total complaints for the 2009 X5 were 13 at CarComplaints.com and 209 at CarProblemZoo.com.

Common issues:

• engine oil leak

2008 BMW X5

There were many issues with the 2008 X5. The failure of the water pump was the most serious issue.

This resulted in a number of symptoms, including engine stalling, coolant leaks, and overheating.

Total complaints for the 2008 X5 were 11 at CarComplaints.com and 313 at CarProblemZoo.com.

Common issues:

• Interior is drenched with water
• power loss while driving
• a faulty coolant pump

2007 and 2006 BMW X5

The 2007 and 2006 BMW X5s both had issues.

The majority of complaints included airbags, with owners reporting that the dashboard airbag warning light would illuminate. There followed a significant recall.

Apart from the airbags, owners also mentioned brake problems, which were connected to the brake vacuum pump failing.

While driving, owners complained about a sudden loss of braking ability.

Total complaints for the 2007 X5 were 6 at CarComplaints.com and 194 at CarProblemZoo.com.

Total complaints for the 2006 X5 were 11 at CarComplaints.com and 229 at CarProblemZoo.com.

Common issues:

• Smoking engine
• on the service engine light
• failing crankcase valves
• Leaking valley pan and gasket
• brake problems

2001 BMW X5

The 2001 X5 was prone to overheating, and for many owners, a faulty cooling fan was the main reason why this was the case.

Total complaints for the 2001 X5 at CarComplaints.com were 12; total problems at CarProblemZoo.com were 172.

Common issues:

• Failure of suspension
• When parked, an electrical fire
• defective dashboard

What Years Have The Most Complaints?

Model Year	Complaints(CarComplaints.com)	Problems(CarProblemZoo.com)
2023 BMW X5	NA	5
2022 BMW X5	NA	11
2021 BMW X5	NA	52
2020 BMW X5	1	20
2019 BMW X5	3	59
2018 BMW X5	2	36
2017 BMW X5	1	71
2016 BMW X5	1	52
2015 BMW X5	4	114
2014 BMW X5	4	88
2013 BMW X5	15	183
2012 BMW X5	17	363
2011 BMW X5	22	403
2010 BMW X5	6	181
2009 BMW X5	13	209
2008 BMW X5	11	313
2007 BMW X5	6	194
2006 BMW X5	11	229
2005 BMW X5	5	106
2004 BMW X5	6	76
2003 BMW X5	5	125
2002 BMW X5	6	123
2001 BMW X5	12	172
2000 BMW X5	0	33

How Safe Is BMW X5?

Depending on the model year, the safety of the BMW X5 varies. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) awarded the 2020 BMW X5 four out of five stars for overall safety and four out of five ratings for the front driver side and front passenger side in frontal crash tests, according to MotorBiscuit.com.

But according to CoPilotSearch.com, the 2013 BMW X5 is one of the worst model years to stay away from, earning a poor 1 out of 5 reliability rating from Consumer Reports and having a host of issues with its fuel system.

When choosing a car, it’s critical to put safety and dependability first and to keep up with any official recalls or safety issues.

The 2020 BMW X3 obtained a “Good” rating from the IIHS and a 5-star overall safety rating from the NHTSA, according to VehicleHistory.com. Although the BMW X3 and X5 are distinct cars, there are some similarities between them.

Reliability of BMW X5

Depending on the model year, the BMW X5 has varying levels of reliability. The 2013 BMW X5 is one of the worst model years to stay away from, according to CoPilotSearch.com, getting a poor 1 out of 5 reliability rating from Consumer Reports, with various issues relating to its fuel system.

However, according to VehicleHistory.com, there have been four generations of the BMW X5, with the most recent being the G05 model, which debuted in 2019.

Reviewers gushed about the handling and the BMW X5’s outstanding six-second zero-to-60 speed, praising the vehicle’s impressive on-road performance. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) gave the 2020 BMW X5 a four-star overall safety rating and four-star ratings in frontal crash testing for both the driver’s and passenger’s sides.

When choosing a car, it’s critical to put safety and dependability first and to keep up with any official recalls or safety issues.

How To Find The Best Deals on BMW X5?

It is advised to check leasing offers, prices, and incentives from various dealers to discover the best offers on a BMW X5. For comparison purposes, U.S. News Best Cars gives details on lease offers, sticker costs, and incentives for the 2023 BMW X3.

For the 2022 BMW X4 and 2022 BMW X3 models, information on incentives and rebates is available on Edmunds.com. A search engine for new BMW X4s is available on CarGurus.com, along with details on costs and special offers for various model years.

Customers may obtain the greatest deal on a BMW X5 by comparing the offers that are available and taking into account the dependability and safety of the car.

Tips for Maintaining your BMW X5

Maintaining a BMW X5 requires regular maintenance and any required repairs.

For owners of the BMW X5, BimmerFest.com offers advice such as washing the car frequently, inspecting the battery connections, and avoiding short trips to maximize battery life. For BMW X5 maintenance procedures that the owner may perform himself, Autodoc.co.uk has a huge selection of repair manuals and video tutorials. Prioritizing safety and dependability is also crucial, as is keeping abreast of any official recalls or security issues.

The 2013 BMW X5 is one of the worst model years to stay away from, according to CoPilotSearch.com, getting a poor 1 out of 5 reliability rating from Consumer Reports, with various issues relating to its fuel system.

It is advised to steer clear of the worst years and take into account the most recent generations of vehicles, such as the G05 model from 2019, which has garnered praise for its handling and performance on the road, according to VehicleHistory.com.

A BMW X5’s life can be prolonged and its dependability ensured by performing routine maintenance, exercising caution when driving, and being informed of any official recalls or safety issues.

How Can You Tell Whether Something Is a Lemon?

Purchase a vehicle history report.

There is no better initial step when purchasing a used car than to obtain a car history report. Two well-known services offer this information for little money: Anyone looking to purchase a used car will find the information provided by CarFax and AutoCheck extremely helpful.

The reports let you know the number of past owners, whether or not it had any accidents, how frequently it required maintenance, and the current title. The final section is among the most crucial since it contains the lemon label, which attests that the car followed the correct legal procedures to be designated as a lemon.

However, in some areas, dealers must inform a customer if the vehicle is a manufacturer buyback, which is a reliable way to determine whether a vehicle has a lemon title.

However, it is the responsibility of the buyer to conduct a thorough investigation into the vehicle’s history. Therefore, consumers may need help if they accidentally purchase a secondhand lemon because they must inspect it first.

Owner Background

You can view the owner’s history on the vehicle history report, which should indicate whether the manufacturer has purchased the vehicle back.

While owners can claim a car is a lemon in a legal dispute and ask the automaker to buy back the problematic vehicle, that is a guaranteed technique to determine if the car was labeled a lemon.

You can also determine if the vehicle was sold or traded before it was given a lemon tag if the prior owner may have missed an issue. It also implies that the car’s persistent issue must be apparent.

Repair Record

Look carefully at the vehicle’s repair record and try to identify any recurring issues. Recurring problems in cars with lemon histories are simple to spot. You can determine whether the issues with the car are minor wear and tear concerns, such as those with the clutch or brakes, or a more severe problem.

Check to discover if the repairs were necessary or carried out even when the car was brand new. It can assist in determining whether the car is a lemon or if an incident like a collision or modification caused a misdiagnosed issue.

Are the repairs significant or minor? A severe repair would deal with the drivetrain or suspension, whereas a superficial one would address non-driving-related issues like window or seat controls. Severe repairs would be more challenging, but handling a car might not be a hassle if a car was considered a lemon for a less severe cause.

The report also shows whether repairs are being made at a dealership or a general shop. Like you would with any used car, examine the vehicle’s general condition and health and determine whether routine maintenance has also been carried out.

This will assist you in deciding whether or not you should consider purchasing this car.

Inspection before purchase

Is the car still a good investment? You should get a pre-purchase inspection if the flaws are not too concerning or if you believe the automobile may have been incorrectly labeled as a lemon.

A mechanic can determine whether the problems are repairable and why the car was considered a lemon. A technician can assist you in determining whether or not a recurring issue is indicative of more severe problems or worries about the quality of the vehicle.

Their satisfaction with the car might help determine if it is a worthwhile investment or a lost cause.

BMW X5 FAQ’s

Which BMW X5 model year is the most dependable?

As already indicated, the 2016, 2017, and 2021 model years of the X5 are excellent choices in terms of dependability and value offer. These more current versions have received excellent reviews for reliability, general performance, and value for the money.

Which BMW X5 engine is the most dependable?

If you’re looking for a strong and dependable BMW engine, the N63 twin turbocharged V8 engine from the F15 X5 is another excellent choice. It is quite potent and 

Are ancient BMW X5s trustworthy?

Are There Any Overall Reliability Ratings For The BMW X5? The overall reliability rating for the BMW X5 is 38.95, which is not very reliable. The exact rankings of this car in relation to various other cars are shown in the chart below, however as a point of reference, the average overall rating is 57.

What is the BMW X5’s biggest issue?

Among the most common complaints made by car owners to the NHTSA are brake and powertrain problems. The 2022 BMW X5 is advertised as a high-end sports car that was built to wow.

Which BMW SUV model year is the most dependable?

You might be surprised to learn that the first-generation E53 X5 is the BMW SUV with the finest reliability record. The greatest years, as well as vehicles with a 3.0L straight-6 mated to a manual transmission, are thought to be 2004 to 2006.